Syllogisms: formulas, shortcuts & solved examples
What it is
A syllogism gives you two or more statements and asks which of the conclusions that follow must be true. You treat the statements as true even if they sound strange, and you accept a conclusion only if it holds in every possible arrangement. The usual tool for this is a Venn diagram.
Key rules
The four statement types
- All A are B. Every A sits inside B. It follows that some A are B, and some B are A.
- No A is B. A and B don't overlap at all. It follows that no B is A.
- Some A are B. A and B overlap at least partly. It follows that some B are A.
- Some A are not B. At least part of A lies outside B. This statement can't be reversed.
Definite or possible
A conclusion follows only if it is true in every diagram consistent with the statements. If it is true in some diagrams but false in others, it does not follow, unless the conclusion itself is worded as a possibility ("Some A being B is a possibility").
Complementary pair (either-or)
When neither conclusion follows on its own, check whether the two are about the same subject and predicate and together cover every case. Examples are "Some A are B" with "No A is B," or "All A are B" with "Some A are not B." If so, the answer is "Either I or II follows."
Shortcuts
Shortcut 1: Draw the weakest diagram
Draw the statements with as little overlap as the rules allow. If a conclusion still holds in this weakest diagram, it is definite. If it breaks, the conclusion doesn't follow.
Shortcut 2: Two particulars give nothing
Two "some" statements never give a definite link between their outer terms. If both statements are particular, a conclusion linking the outer terms will not follow.
Shortcut 3: Reverse the statement when you can
"Some A are B" can be read as "Some B are A," and "No A is B" as "No B is A." Many conclusions are simply these reversals, and checking for them first saves time.
Solved examples
Example 1
Statements: All pens are books. Some books are bags. Conclusions: I. Some pens are bags. II. Some books are pens.
Pens sit inside books. The bags may overlap with books in the part that contains no pens, so conclusion I is not certain. "All pens are books" means some books are pens, so conclusion II is certain. Answer: Only II follows.
Example 2
Statements: No cat is a dog. All dogs are animals. Conclusions: I. Some animals are not cats. II. No animal is a cat.
Dogs sit inside animals, and none of the dogs are cats. That gives some animals (the dogs) that are not cats, so conclusion I is certain. Cats could still overlap with the part of animals that isn't dogs, so conclusion II is not certain. Answer: Only I follows.
Example 3
Statements: Some teachers are doctors. No doctor is a lawyer. Conclusions: I. Some teachers are not lawyers. II. Some lawyers are teachers.
The teachers who are doctors can't be lawyers, so conclusion I is certain. Lawyers might overlap with the teachers who aren't doctors, but nothing forces this, so conclusion II is only possible. Answer: Only I follows.
Example 4
Statements: All roses are flowers. Some flowers are red. Conclusions: I. Some roses are red. II. No rose is red.
Neither conclusion is certain. The red region may or may not reach the roses. However, I and II are about the same two terms, and exactly one of them must be true. Answer: Either I or II follows.
Common mistakes
- Using real-world knowledge. If a statement says "All fish are birds," accept it as true. Judge the conclusion only by the given statements.
- Reversing "All." "All A are B" does not mean "All B are A." It only tells you that some B are A.
- Accepting conclusions that are only possible. Something that could be true is not the same as something that must be true. Unless the conclusion is worded as a possibility, reject it.
- Choosing "either-or" too easily. The pair must have the same subject and predicate, and one conclusion must contradict the other. Two unrelated conclusions that both fail mean "Neither follows."
- Reversing "Some A are not B." This statement can't be turned around. "Some A are not B" tells you nothing about whether some B are not A.
Practice now: https://www.testsworld.com/mocks